By Bob Cowser, Jr.
Artifact: Encounters With Campus Shooting Archives by Julija Šukys
Julija Šukys often refers to the distinction made by noted Canadian archival studies scholar Terry Cook between an “archive” and an “archives”: the former represents the repository that encapsulates the ongoing work of the latter. An ‘archival essayist’ like Šukys doesn’t merely seek order among assembled materials of an archive but must look beyond the documents into the realm of ideas, with an orientation that is metaphorical and philosophical. “We… come quietly in the wake of such tragedies… to give meaning to such tragedies,” she writes.
The archival essay is clearly her niche. As Šukys explains in her introduction, the height of her training in comparative literature at McGill University in the 1990s coincided with an “archival turn” in humanities scholarship which rendered everything an archive: “institutions, memory, junk shops, museums, cemeteries, even gardens.” In three previous award-winning books, Šukys has used personal correspondence and archival material to reconstruct the lives of 1) an assassinated Algerian poet 2) a Lithuanian librarian who aided Jews during the Nazi occupation of the capital city of Vilnius, and 3) her own paternal grandparents who endured a twenty-five-year forced separation following World War II.
But her new effort, Artifact, is “personal” in another way. The book examines five North American campus shootings: École Polytechnique de Montreal (1989) and Concordia University (1992) in Canada and Virginia Tech (2007), Alabama-Huntsville (2010) and Umpqua Community College in Oregon (2015) in the United States, where shooters and victims might have been the author’s students or faculty colleagues. Perhaps even more importantly, Šukys, now a professor in creative writing and comparative literature at UT-Austin, chose to explore these shootings because they “to [her] mind constituted an attack on the university institution itself.” Šukys goes on to write, “The innocent bystander-victim in all this is the ideal of university life, a life of research, writing, contemplation, and mentorship,” a sacred, familial space where the author has always felt the greatest sense of happiness and belonging. “I went to the archives to see how the university had fared under duress and in the aftermath of tragedy,” she explains in introductory material, “to learn how it records and remembers pain.”
To read the book is to follow Šukys as she examines journalistic accounts, legal filings, memorials, personal interviews that fill these boxes. She sorts her text into seven imagined file boxes, a box for each shooting plus one box each for introductory and summative reflections. Each box is subdivided into folders and all the boxes are ultimately grouped in series: Series One includes the introduction and material about the two Canadian shootings, Two includes the material about the shootings at Virginia Tech and Alabama-Huntsville, and Series Three includes material from the Oregon community college (which has to date established no real archives, perhaps explaining its sequestration in the box with the author’s final testimony).
But the text is neither mere catalog nor narrative reconstruction of the individual shootings; film scholar Timothy Corrigan would describe a book like Artifact as the record of the writer’s shifting subjectivity as it encounters public experiences (in this case, the campus shootings), as it sorts and “weighs out” all of this evidence. As in Joan Didion’s “Sentimental Journeys” or James Baldwin’s Evidence of Things Not Seen, it is the author’s reflections, her questions primarily, that organize the text. As a Canadian who relocated to the U.S. with her husband (also an academic) and son, she brings a wary detachment to the project despite her early confession that the attachments feel personal.
For example, in the context of the 1982 École Polytechnique shooting where rejected applicant Marc Lépine shot fourteen engineering students (all targeted because they were women), Šukys asks if there is “a way to engage with records of violence and cruelty without exploiting victims and survivors?” In the case of Concordia University engineering professor Valery Fabrikant, who shot five colleagues in a classroom building in 1992, killing two, she notes the shooter’s prominence in the files, how Fabricant seems to overshadow his victims in the aftermath. Of course it is common practice in contemporary media to censor images of victims, to name shooting victims but avoid naming their killers (lest the shooters gain the notoriety they sought in the first place). But taking a cue from the man she calls the hero of her book, former Concordia University communications director Ken Whittingham, she writes extensively about Fabricant. (I confess to having found him oddly fascinating, a Luigi Mangione/Ted Kaczynski-type figure). Whittingham had advocated for truthfulness and disclosure over “the whiting out of key names,” risking criticism about the university’s incompetence (inquiries concluded that some charges Fabricant made against colleagues had merit) to avoid the greater trauma inflicted by redactions and social silence. In 1992, Whittingham’s historical comparison for such a societal wound is the 1972 Watergate scandal, but I could not help but think, reading Šukys’s book in the winter of 2026 as I experienced the yawning agony of the Trump administration’s (mis)handling of the Jeffrey Epstein files, that these seem an even better analogy. “To refuse to allow for cataclysm to do its work of transformation,” writes Šukys, “produces a community that can neither see nor tell the truth.”
Šukys’s detachment allows her to eschew the sentimental, and this reader is grateful. She does so gracefully, with questions instead of judgements. Recalling eminent poet and Virginia Tech professor Nikki Giovanni’s commencement poem delivered following the shooting there in 2007, which concludes with the refrain “We will prevail,” Šukys wonders what has become of that Utopian moment, whether ‘moving on’ should be the default move in the aftermath of tragedy. (The spirit of the archival essayist tends, instead, to linger.) In a folder entitled “Forgiveness,” Šukys includes the testimony of Alabama-Huntsville Biology professor Deb Moriarity, who acknowledges her enduring concern for her incarcerated colleague Amy Bishop, the former colleague who shot three other biology professors dead before a meeting in 2010. “Other people in the department are like, she’s dead to them or they wish she’d rot in hell but I can’t do that.”
Šukys regularly consults contemporary archival theorists or masters like Baldwin or Susan Sontag or Judith Butler in formulating answers to the questions her research raises, but I appreciate her own instincts, too. The author’s subjectivity is so fundamental in this kind of encounter—readers will note its traces in the text (like her Canadian’s bewilderment at American gun craziness—that it is paramount that we trust Julija Šukys as our witness). Artifact has all the hallmarks of good, trustworthy essaying: careful observation, a keen synthesizing intellect, and the principled cultivation of self-doubt. Her final research visit, to Umpqua Community College in Oregon, where in 2015 Chris Harper-Mercer, a twenty-six-year-old student who killed an assistant professor and eight students and injured eight others, threatens to undermine her entire project—the school has kept no archive of the shooting. Šukys is most trustworthy and her book most successful because even here she acknowledges these doubts. “Having come to the end of this journey,” she writes, “I now suspect I have been asking the wrong question all along.” Only such humility and circumspection render such a journey so worthwhile.
West Virginia University Press
$18.99 Paperback | Buy Here
Bob Cowser, Jr. is the author of 3 nonfiction books, most recently GREEN FIELDS: CRIME, PUNISHMENT AND A BOYHOOD BETWEEN, which won “Best Memoir 2010” from the Adirondack Center for Writers and was cited in the Best American Essays 2012. His first book DREAM SEASON was named a NEW YORK TIMES editor’s choice and was listed among the “best-ever college sports books” by THE CHRONICLE OF HIGHER EDUCATION. He is also the editor of 2 anthologies, most recently THE EDINBURGH COMPANION TO THE ESSAY (co-edited with Nicole Wallack and Mario Aquilina). He has taught nonfiction writing and film at St. Lawrence University since 1998.















































































































































